This is my space to share my quest to collect as many broken branches as I can in my fractured family tree which resembles a bramble bush more then a proper tree. As I go forward in this blogging journey I hope to share how I have searched far & wide for family - with no regard for where they come from or if I should really want them.
You can pick your friends, but you can't pick your family you know!

Sunday, April 28, 2019

Reverend Alonzo Vannatter ~ Brethren In Christ Church, Frogmore, Ontario

52 Ancestors in 52 Weeks: Week 17 (At Worship)


This week's prompt AT WORSHIP posed no hesitation on who I would feature. My husband's great grandfather was a Reverend in a small town in Houghton Township, Ontario. 

When I first started hearing the stories about Asa Alonzo Vannatter (known as Lonnie to those close to him) I loved that his church was in a town called Frogmore.


Brethren In Christ church in Frogmore, Ontario, Canada  ~ 2007


Throughout my husband's growing up he was close to extended family. All of his grandparents & great grandparents played a vital part in his formative years. His great grandfather Vannatter was a larger than life character for him. 

My husband with his great grandfather, publication and date unknown


This write up in a church document shows why that would be. 


"   Rev. Alonzo Vannatter is described in Roy V. Sider's introduction to the book as being "one of the great but little known men of the Brethren in Christ. No man could be more loyal in crisis than he was. Godliness and good humour rarely find a better mix than they did in Alonzo Vannatter." Vannatter's qualities as a person and as a pastor may be seen in this paragraph that he has given us: "Rose early, did my chores . . . got ready for church, about nine miles for the 10 a.m. Sunday School and preaching service at 11. At 12 o'clock started home and then changed horses and drove to Bethel, about 7 miles, for 2 p.m. Sunday School and preaching service at 3, them home to chores and supper and at 7:30 p.m. conducted worship service at Frogmore."   "(
1)  




My husband at the Church in Frogmore, Ontario in 2007 in front of the pastors photos
(his great grandfather, Alonzo, second from left)

 Asa Alonzo Vannatter was the 5th of 6 children born to Benjamin Augustus Vannatter and Sophia Fidella Foreman. He was born on the 23rd of November in 1901 in Frogmore, Houghton Township, Norfolk, Ontario, Canada. 

On the 2nd of January 1923 he married Vera Catharine Williams in Cultus, Ontario, Canada.

Vera was born on September 27th 1902 in Norfolk County, Ontario Canada. Her parents were George Albert Williams and Edith Gertrude Brisseau. 

Alonzo and Vera were parents to 5 children: 4 girls and a boy. My husbands' grandmother was their 2nd born. None of their children strayed far from their parents. Most of the extended family still lives in the area. They stayed very connected to all their children, grandchildren, and great grandchildren. 


Alonzo died on April 8th 1976 in London, Ontario, Canada. Vera died on March 25th 1981 in Tillsonburg, Ontario. They were both buried in Cultus Cemetery, Cultus, Norfolk, Ontario, Canada.


Cultus Cemetery, Cultus, Norfolk, Ontario, Canada



While working on this blog I decided to search for any entries I could find. I was able to find many records of Reverend Alonzo Vannatter in marriage and funeral records (a few copied below). The best find was this document about  the history of the Brethren in Chris church where there is much more information to read (link in the sources at that end). The book referenced below is written by Rev. Alonzo & Rev. Sider. We have a copy of. It was a gift to my husband from his grandmother who was very proud of her father. 

Retrieved April 28th 2019  from Brethren in Christ - History and Life archives  http://bicarchives.messiah.edu/files/Documents18/1982-2-december_1982.pdf




Evangelical Visitor Archives, retrieved April 28th 2019 from http://bicarchives.messiah.edu/files/Documents9/1971-05-10_may_10,1971.pdf




Evangelical Visitor Archives, retrieved April 28th 2019 from http://bicarchives.messiah.edu/files/Documents11/1954-09-27_sep_27,1954.pdf




Evangelical Visitor Archives retrieved April 28th 2019 from http://bicarchives.messiah.edu/files/Documents13/1968-02-26_feb_26,1968.pdf




Evangelical Visitor archives, retrieved April 28th 2019 from http://bicarchives.messiah.edu/files/Documents13/1968-09-09_sep_09,1968.pdf




Evangelical Visitor archives, retrieved April 28th 2019 from http://bicarchives.messiah.edu/files/Documents11/1954-09-27_sep_27,1954.pdf




Evangelical Visitor archives,  retrieved April 28th 2019 from http://bicarchives.messiah.edu/files/Documents10/1948-10-04_oct_4,1948.pdf




Evangelical Visitor archive, retrieved April 28th 2019 from http://bicarchives.messiah.edu/files/Documents12/1961-05-15_may_15,1961.pdf



Finding family history by searching for documents & details.




This is why I search - 

Cause ... 






You can pick your friends, but you can't pick your family you know!



***Any errors are my own. Please send me any updates or corrections via the comments at the bottom of this blog post***


Sources

(1Brethern in Christ, History and Life, December 1982, Retrieved April 25, 2019 from
http://bicarchives.messiah.edu/files/Documents18/1982-2-december_1982.pdf


If you reference or use my blog posts in any way please
include a link to the specific blog and
credit http://somehowrelated.blogspot.com/
My blogs are ©Deborah Buchner, 2014 forward.
All rights reserved.
Please & Thank you!

Tuesday, April 16, 2019

In Memory ~ Our Canine Family Member

52 Ancestors in 52 Weeks: Week 16 (Out Of Place)


This week's prompt OUT OF PLACE left me a smidge stumped. I really do have quite a few black sheep in my tree so really there is a lot out of place. What is actually out of place in my tree are the details that fit nicely. I thought about writing about one of my ancestors that was super easy to research, but then changed my mind. What would be more out of place in my family tree than the canine family member who passed away last week.

January 2015 Siska arrived to our home along with my mother who was fighting terminal cancer. When my mother passed away in March of 2015 Siska continued living with us. She missed mom. She was already attached to us because we had been her sitters whenever mom went away. She and our dog were best friends. Siska stayed close to Tori all the time. She would sit on her bigger friend. 
They slept together. They played hard.  


Siska was happy, but still missed mom. For many months after mom died Siska would greet us at the door upon arriving home, and wait. She was expecting mom to walk through that door behind whoever had just arrived home. It was heartbreaking. Siska was special, and like many we love she was also annoying at times.

     




She even made friends with the cats.






For a hunting dog she was gentle with other critters




In remembering Siska I will go back to the beginning of her story with our family. In 2010 my mom lost her dog Ruby shortly after losing my step dad who had been my dad from the age of 8. Mom felt that getting another dog was a bad idea because she lived alone. It wasn't long before she realized living alone in a rural type area didn't feel safe so she asked me to find her a dog. She said that she was looking for a purebred fox terrier because Ruby had been Jack Russell/Fox Terrier, and she thought the traits she had really loved of Ruby were the Fox Terrier. She said she wanted the dog to be: fox terrier, female, short haired, about 3, fixed, and affordable. I replied that she couldn't just give me a shopping list and expect me to produce a dog for her. She said it had worked in the past when I found her 2 other dogs. I wasn't so confident it would work this time. I was pretty sure that her previous shopping lists hadn't been this detailed. 

A few days later I sat at my computer, and entered her shopping list along with my hometown in a search bar. I was stunned when an ad appeared on our local for sale site: female - check, 3 years - check, fixed - check, purebred fox terrier - check (no papers), short hair - check (photo), affordable - uh oh (too much).  I sent a message off to the seller thinking we could negotiate, and I could pay for part as her upcoming birthday present. After emailing back and forth for about a day I finally arranged to meet the dog. When the seller gave me her address I was shocked to discover that this dog was our neighbour. She lived in a house within visual distance of our front porch. The house's maintenance was pretty rough. We had heard the dog being yelled at, seen it dragged around on it's leash, heard it's high pitch barking without being answered. This was a dog that didn't appear to be very well behaved, but after watching Cesar Millan we knew the problem lied with the owners. She  was only 3 years old, and could be trained. I messaged mom that I found her shopping list dog, and the dog needed her more than she needed it. Mom asked how much. I told her that we weren't talking about that since it was her birthday and Christmas present for the next 2 years. She asked if I had even tried negotiating. Mom knew me very well. If there was a deal to be had she would always make it, but that has never been my talent. I told her we were worried that we would lose the sale if we tried, and this dog really needed saving. When we picked her up the seller told us she was super easy to feed because she only ate people food, and would need her shots because she hasn't had any while living with the seller. 

Challenge #1 for mom was getting her to eat dog food (mix it with treats). Challenge #2 was getting her to stop peeing in the house (install doggy door). Challenge #3 was to get her to stop barking at things mom left in the wrong place (put broom away after use). Challenge #4 was getting her to not bark at the bush in the yard in the middle of the night (lock doggy door at night & clean up pee). Challenge #5 was to get her to stop barking at loud noises (stop using dishwasher, give away hand mixer, don't use microwave). 

Mom took Siska to the vet for a check up and shots and was told that the dog was closer to 7 years old & he saw evidence that she had been used as a breeding dog. The paperwork that arrived with her now made sense. It had looked like the seller had her almost 2 years, and the previous owner had her about 2 years after getting her from a breeder in a neighbouring town. It looked like mom's 3 year old dog aged 4 extra years overnight. Teaching an old dog new tricks made working on her behaviour more challenging.  I can't remember what her original name was. Mom renamed her Siska after my Belgian grandma who called all the critters and us grandkids this pet name.  Siska and mom were inseparable. 

Mom tucked that dog under her arm, and took her everywhere.

By the time mom and Siska arrived with us the only behaviour we had to work on was my unwillingness to give up my dishwasher, microwave, and hand mixer. In the years after mom passed away Siska learned to ignore the dishwasher and microwave. The handmixer she would pace nervously, but not get too excited. When we first started putting her on a leash we attached her halter to Tori who is very well behaved on leash. Tori taught Siska how to walk respectfully on a leash. She also taught Siska how to ring the bells at the back door to alert someone she needed to go out. For the first while this novelty had us considering the removal of the bells, and just cleaning up pee. Those bells were ringing non-stop until the novelty finally wore off, and she used them when she truly had need.  Without a doggy door she often had accidents in the house. We live in an urban area, and the doggy door would need to be too big for both dogs to use it. This was one of those annoying things we learned to live with. 

Last summer my grandma was sick, and I took Siska with me to look after Grandma. Mom had often taken Siska with her to stay overnight with Grandma. Maybe Siska would be good for Grandma's recovery. When we arrived to Grandma's Independent facility Siska remembered where she was going. She marched in leading me to where we needed to go. She strutted like a rock star. Whenever we saw any of the seniors who lived in the building she would stop, and await their greeting and admiration. When someone walked by without greeting her you could almost hear her scorn that they were unaware of the famous Siska. In that week Siska worked miracles. Grandma would sit with her, and pet her. You could almost see Grandma getting better with every minute she and Siska were together.  The healing power of dogs is well known. For Grandma it was a tie to her precious daughter who had died. It was quite beautiful to see them together. When I was thanked for all I had done for grandma I let them know that I was simply Siska's wheels she was the true star of the moment. 


If I was being honest I would say that I simply did what mom needed me to do. One evening talking to my cousin I had been thinking that it was too bad that Grandma was sick, but it wasn't my responsibility since I'm a grandchild and not the child. That night I woke up in the middle of the night knowing that I had to go to look after Grandma and take the dog. I'm pretty sure the message I received came right from my mom who was directing me to go in her place to help out her siblings who were exhausted and could use a break. Mom was the oldest, and often stayed overnight with Grandma. She would have been there taking her turn. The timing was all wrong for me to go. There is no way I would have come up with the decision to take the dog on my own. There was also no way I would ignore my mother's direction to go. 

Siska was a great traveler, but a demanding travel companion. Wandering around a quiet neighbourhood in the middle of the night so she wouldn't pee in Grandma's apartment was not my idea of a good nighttime routine. That week was not only healing for Grandma, but it was for me as well. I hadn't been back to my home town since mom died, and that trip I discovered you can go home. 

Before mom died she asked me to send my grandma (her mom) a tall stack of word searches at Christmas every year because Siska always gave them to Grandma for Christmas. Mom died in March. In May I would have my first Mother's day without mom when I realized grandma was having her first Mother's Day without her daughter. In a bubble envelope I sent a thinking of you card with a pawprint sticker in it and no other writing along with a few word search books and a sweet treat. That became the tradition for us. Rather than sending a large stack at Christmas Siska sent a bubble envelope at Valentine's Day, Mother's Day, mom's birthday, Grandma's birthday, and Christmas. Every single one of those packages came with no human writing besides the addressing on the envelope. They were from the dog, and had dog footprint stickers. Certain holidays and celebrations were times I really missed my mom. Although they were gifts for Grandma they were really my way of honouring my mom. They were part of my grief healing process. 

As Siska got older she was not able to keep up on the long walks Tori craved so we found a solution.




The hardest part about losing Siska was that she was my last tangible connection to my mom. There must have been quite a puppy celebration as Siska crossed over the rainbow bridge to find mom and meet Dad & Ruby and all the other furry friends that came before her. 



Remembering those we have lost.




This is why I search - 

Cause ... 








You can pick your friends, but you can't pick your family you know!



***Any errors are my own. Please send me any updates or corrections via the comments at the bottom of this blog post***


Photos

Personal


If you reference or use my blog posts in any way please
include a link to the specific blog and
credit http://somehowrelated.blogspot.com/
My blogs are ©Deborah Buchner, 2014 forward.
All rights reserved.
Please & Thank you!


Saturday, April 13, 2019

Searching Far & Wide ~ Found Across Town

52 Ancestors in 52 Weeks: Week 15 (DNA)


All the names this week have been changed for privacy sake since they deal with living folks. The only name that is real is mine.  I decided alias names would allow for my story to flow nicely while still protecting the privacy of my new found cousins.

I first began searching because I descend from at least 3 black sheep which resulted in my having no idea where my family came from. I waited patiently for Ancestry DNA to become available in Canada so I could finally figure it all out. The announcement was made that it would be available in Canada a few months after my birthday. My husband gave me a homemade gift certificate for Ancestry DNA in my birthday card that year. I waited patiently until I could order it. Waited patiently for the kit to arrive. Waited impatiently for the test to be processed. Was surprised when the email arrived saying the results were available about a week before expected. 


I quickly signed in to see my results feeling super excited that all would be revealed.  I was sad to see that I had a long list of extended relatives in the distant cousin range with no way of figuring out how they were related to me. I did have one closer 2nd cousin match, but I was already collaborating with him so his match didn't provide any more information. 

About a year later I convinced my dad to do his Ancestry DNA, and then later still my mom's mom and sister did theirs for me. With all of these DNA matches I was able to figure out how I was related to many of the matches, and my tree began to expand in ways that traditional paper researching may not have done for me.

Sometime last summer I signed on to Ancestry to find that I had some new DNA matches to explore. I found that I had two that the only in commons were the three of us. I sent a message to them both. 6 Months went by, and I never heard anything from either of them. Finally one of them replied saying that they were adopted so didn't have much info for me besides the name of their natural father's mother, Iris Fletcher. This person said that they didn't know anything besides the name. I immediately replied that I had grown up listening to my grandmother's Iris Tales, and had quite a bit on that side of the family in my tree. I sent an invite to my tree. I now had a little more information to send to the other match we had in common. I sent a more detailed email outlining what I knew about  our connection, and asked if they were related to Iris' sister Holly. This time I also mentioned where I lived, and added my last name.

In mere minutes I received a response asking if I was married to Carson Buchanan. My immediate thought was 'really, what does he have to do with my dad's side of the tree'. I asked Carson to come look at my computer monitor. He looked over my shoulder, and says "Oh yah, it's Rob". I'm sitting there surprised, and ask him "How do you know Robert Chapman?". Carson says "You know him too. I worked with him here before he moved back to his home community."  He then casually mentioned that Robert's mom Jenny lives across town.

I had been searching far & wide for folks on all branches of my tree, and all this time some of the answers were just across town. 

The story becomes even more shocking when I realized that Jenny had been attending a genealogy group at my work's other location. The same location I had worked at previously, and very likely helped Jenny a time or two.  At no time did Jenny's research produce the fact that I was living locally.

Then I discovered my husband sat at Jenny's table with clear view to a family photo that I have. It didn't look familiar to him because hers is large, in colour and framed. Mine is this small black & white photocopy. 


Slicer Family
Back: Jane, Peter, Dave, Lizzie (my great grandmother)
Front: Eva, Father (Peter), Jimmy, Adam, Mother (Marion nee Jack), Mary
(as recorded with the photo by the cousin who provided the photo)

The initial email exchange with Robert Chapman took place shortly before Thanksgiving 2018. That Thanksgiving we had had cousin Jenny join us. A while later Jenny's sister came to visit, and I met another new cousin. At Christmas Robert came over, and cooked us an amazing prime rib meal. Throughout all three visits the conversations revolved around how folks were related, what they were doing now, and many photos were shared. 

Since that time I was able to use Ancestry DNA matches along with MyHeritage to confirm the research in my tree. I have gotten a couple of generations further up the tree. I now have more cousins who know a whole lot more about my family tree than my side of the family ever knew.



When searching far & wide don't forget to look in your very own neighbourhood.




This is why I search - 

Cause ... 








You can pick your friends, but you can't pick your family you know!



***Any errors are my own. Please send me any updates or corrections via the comments at the bottom of this blog post***


If you reference or use my blog posts in any way please
include a link to the specific blog and
credit http://somehowrelated.blogspot.com/
My blogs are ©Deborah Buchner, 2014 forward.
All rights reserved.
Please & Thank you!


Saturday, April 6, 2019

3 Bricks in the Wall ~ Thomas Thomson (Stonemason, Brick House, Genealogical Brick Wall)


52 Ancestors in 52 Weeks: Week 14 (Brick Wall)


#8 Clifford Road, backyard,  retrieved from Google Maps Streetview April 1, 2019

My great grandfather Thomas Thomson (jr) was a stonemason. He lived in the brick houses pictured below. He is also my brick wall for researching. I think he nicely covers this week's prompt of BRICK WALL

The reason he is my genealogical brick wall is that he belongs to a family full of Thomas Thomsons from Scotland. His hometown of North Berwick is full of Thomsons, and his grandmother's married and maiden name were both Thomson. Further complicating online searching is that he shares a name with a famous Canadian artist. Searching for a connection between my family and the artists family is for another time.  

Back at the beginning of my searching journey I found a 2nd cousin X1 removed in New Zealand who had paid for genealogy researching in the relevant areas of Scotland. His research and details assisted me greatly in my confidence of my tree searching. When I first met Murray I expressed my disappointment that his ancestor had a very cool unique name (James Devlin Glass Thomson) whereas mine was boring (Thomas Thomson). It didn't take me long to realize both carried family history that we both could be proud of.

In the modern day of Family searches for Family Tree (Genealogy) Google Street View is amazing. I think Google Street View is a fabulous tool for reference as noted in the scenario below – this time mine, but it could be anyone’s family. I was able to input the address of the old family home in Scotland where my Grandmother was born, and see it standing today as it was when my grandmother was a baby.The second photo had the house name CRAIGIELEA on the back with Great Auntie Maisie standing in front of it, and the note on the back said that it was down the street. My dad and I sat at my computer in Canada, and 'walked' the street looking at each house while holding the photo until we found the correct house and noted that the address was #20 Clifford Road. Online searching found a listing for Craigielea at #20 Clifford Road. Those brick houses were built to last. 


Both houses on Clifford Road in the photos were designed and built by James Glass who was Thomas's uncle. James was the brother of Isabella Glass married to Thomas Thomson (sr). Thomas & Isabella (nee Glass) Thomson were parents of Thomas Thomson( (jr.) married to Elizabeth Young Slicer. Elizabeth's brother, Peter Slicer, assisted in building Craigielea. 


My great grandfather's British Army WW1 Service Record records the family's residence as #8 Clifford Road, North Berwick in 1915. My grandmother was born in December 1915. She was born at #8 Clifford Road. I believe her older sister Marion (known as Maisie) was born at their grandparents home, Craigielea #20 Clifford Road. Their grandparents were Peter & Marion (nee Jack) Slicer. Both the Thomson & Slicer families were residing at Clifford Road in North Berwick by 1901 according to the census records. Thomas Thomson (jr.) & Elizabeth Young Slicer were married the 31st of December 1908 when he was 28 and she 26. They had been neighbours for a minimum of 7 years prior to their marriage.  


Clifford Road, #8 on the left, #6 on the right, retrieved from Google Maps April 1, 2019




  Craigielea, #20 Clifford Road, North Berwick, Scotland, retrieved from Google Maps April 1, 2019






Recorded on back as Craigielea, Marion (nee Jack) Slicer & one of her daughters

















































I haven't yet found the records of when Thomas (jr.) & family originally arrived in Canada, and built their house in Calgary. My grandmother told me that her parents had difficulty conceiving and carrying children so when Elizabeth got pregnant in 1913 the couple decided to return to Scotland for family assistance for the impending birth. They rented their house in Calgary out to a young couple, and went home to Scotland by ship to await their first child. The first daughter was born in Scotland in May 1914, and before they could head back to Calgary World War 1 broke out in July of 1914, and they were trapped in The United Kingdom (Scotland) until after the war. Their second daughter (my grandmother) was born in December 1915. 



Elizabeth Young (nee Slicer) Thomson with daughter Marion & Mary
note on back: "Dad had this picture in France during WW1" as recorded by daughter Marion


After the war the family returned to Canada via ship in 1920, and returned to their home in Calgary where the couple who was still caring for their home moved out, and grandma and her family moved back into the house. She resided in the home her father built (Thomas Thomson jr. - the Stonemason) in Calgary until she married my Grandfather in 1942. 

While growing up in Canada my grandmother and her family traveled to the United States where her father's mason skills were sought. There are buildings in several places in the United States that feature his stone gargoyles & others. He also carved and created in many places in Canada and Scotland. Sadly I have not seen any of his public work, and don't know exactly where his pieces are located. I have only seen two small stone carvings he did for his two daughters.


Many of the old census records list the residence address which makes looking the address up fairly easy. Many of the old residences are no longer as they were, but some are still - as I found in North Berwick for my ancestors.




Take a walk down memory lane with Google Street view.




This is why I search - 

Cause ... 








You can pick your friends, but you can't pick your family you know!



***Any errors are my own. Please send me any updates or corrections via the comments at the bottom of this blog post***



Sources:

Robertson, Mary Elizabeth (nee Thomson), as recorded by her granddaughter, the writer of this blog. 


Craigielea listing retrieved April 1, 2019 fromhttp://www.192.com/address/details/north+berwick/eh39+4pw/craigielea+20/




If you reference or use my blog posts in any way please
include a link to the specific blog and
credit http://somehowrelated.blogspot.com/
My blogs are ©Deborah Buchner, 2014 forward.
All rights reserved.
Please & Thank you!